Deliciously creative cupcakes baked with a variety of toppings and ingredients.

Baked Donuts

Baked donuts coated with delectable toppings are a lighter and equally delicious version of donuts without the frying!

Farmer’s Market

Our products will be available at various farmer’s markets in New York and on Long Island. Check back here for the latest updates and locations!

Thanks again for the cupcakes! We all love the design, frosting, and the cake tastes amazing! You are the best!

– Lex

I love everything about Sarah’s Cupcakery , we always get an amazingly designed cupcake with a piece of heaven in each bite.

– Joseph


Life's a Beach

Sunshine summer beach cake

Cinderella Cake

Four-layer iced princess cake

Cinnamon Roll Cookies

Two awesome desserts ROLLED into one

Shortbread Bites

Bite-sized happiness

Melting Snowmen

Some people are worth melting for

Gingerbread Christmas Tree

A new take on gingerbread houses


Here comes the sun

Oh Christmas Tree

The Christmas tree you don't mind taking down

Holiday Wreaths

Have yourself a merry little Christmas

Big-eyed Owls

Hoo cute to eat

Hockey Champions

Ice hockey cupcakes for any team

Happy Camper

Smores cupcakes

Pumpkin Pie

Classic Thanksgiving treat

Cranberry Walnut Tart

Indecision's favorite treat

Easter Baskets

Easter baskets, chicks, and butterfly cupcakes

American Flag

Patriotic independence cake

4th of July cupcakes

Perfect independence day snacks


$3.00 - Premium Cupcakes

In order to create the freshest and most delectable cupcakes, we make all our cupcakes from scratch with no preprocessed materials!

  • Uniquely imagined and designed

  • Premium cake, icing, and toppings

  • Premium toppings and fillings

  • Mini cupcakes also available

Premium Cupcakes

Our Team

Sarah M.

A modern day cupcake artist who's true passion can be sampled in every bite

Follow Us